Save Fritjof: +2 Pirates Each
Threnody, the druids seem all cool with each other. Being Neutral and all, it's easy to get along. Funny how 'Good' translates into 'Fucking Idiot', 'Neutral' is 'I Don't Give a Shit', and 'Evil' means 'Always Lies and Steals and Attacks My Friends'.
Back to the combat!
KT and Theo, you guys heal. KT, you direct the spiderbot to stop attacking the blue elf mage and go help Theo vs. the harpoonist.
Theo, dropping a darkness is a great idea. You shut down the harpoonist and the pirates in the vicinity.
That is, until the elf mage sees what's going on, and busts a Light to cancel the Darkness.
Okay Thren, you shoot some guys on the way up. That means you're a target too, obviously. You get hit twice, for 11! You've taken 14 now, you're hurting bad.
You then Shuriken Storm a bunch of guys, and a couple pirates drop.
Just to make it easier, everyone's got two pirates on them. Even you Tut- a couple guys leap into the water, swim over, and climb on board Shamu's back to come at you with spears and blades.