Wow That's A Pretty Darn Good 1st Level THAC0
You're 1st level, and your THAC0 is 14? Here are your rolls from below:
16 - 8 - 14 - 16 - 2 - 8- 6 - 4
Let's see, spec bow doesn't do x2 damage, and so it shouldn't cost 3 prof slots. Only 2. That's fine, you use your third and final (4 from fighter, 2 from cleric, round in the middle = 3) to take prof longsword.
DEX 18 gives you +3 with missile weapons. As an elf, you get +1 to hit, and with spec, another +2. Huh, okay, you're THAC0 14. Maybe I need to hire a few more pirates.
Anyway, your BRs now translate into hitting ACs: -2, 6, 0, -2, 12, 6, 8, and 10. That's two hits the first round, two the second, one the third and one the fourth. Let's revise...
Assuming 5.5 pts of dmg per hit including spec bonus, you'll drop a total of three pirates.
Okay, just to clean up to the present then, it won't matter if Tut2 has spec or not, I'll just retroactively apply damage. There's all of two foes left:
One wounded pirate on Thaka Zulu, and Frank Burton, who lights up a cigar on Azoth's prone boot. "Next! Take a fuckin' number, you demi-human freaks. What the hell is this, the Carnival cruise? Player's Handbook On Parade?"