Master Apprentice Steve APG Spills The Beans
"D'oh," says Steve, when you corner him in a dark Grito alley.
"Uh how's it goin Marion. Um... so I guess I didn't really kill that Skullbones guy. Are you gonna tell on me?" Steve looks pretty worried about it. "Actually I didn't kill any of those undead guys. That death knight just fireballed everybody. I guess I can't really cast fireball. And I just pretended a piece of lumber was a Fireball Staff."
Steve hangs his head in shame. "Sorry dude. It's just that everyone started getting excited and callin me a hero and stuff and I really wanted to be a hero. I didn't really know what to say. Then next thing I know, I'm Master of the Potion Guild and it was pretty cool. Like even this girl Vanessa said 'hey' to me. Then the Knights of Marmaduke show up and kill everyone, which was just awful, and I couldn't do anything about it. I guess I'm not much of a hero, huh? That sucks."
Your WI is pretty bad, but you get the sense that Steve is sincere on a WI check at +4, for whatever that's worth to you. "Hey look, if you just wanna keep this between you and me, I'll give you whatever potions you want?" For whatever
that's worth to you.