Level I Treasure
Okay, Marivhon you grab the halberd. Later, you attack the orc and miss. Whatever the halberd is, it doesn't grant you +4 to hit I guess.
Brogg, you disintegrate the last orc. The Fightmaster announces that the combat is over.
Three things again appear on the altar. You can have one. A small wooden chest, a small burlap sack, and a large leather pouch.
You then take another day to rest up, heal to full, and recover all spells. Cross off that extra day of food.
Now what?